CRYSTAL REVIEWS

A PLACE WHERE READERS AND REVIEWERS CAN

EXPLORE AND APPRECIATE THE CRAFT OF WRITING

IN BOOK FORM!

REVIEWERS INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATION MEMBER!

RIO Web Site

 

HOME

REVIEWS BY:

AUTHOR

GENRE

TITLE

New York Times Best Sellers

NY Times Chapter One

REVIEWERS

CRYSTAL EDITING SERVICES

IT MIGHT HAVE BEEN WHAT HE SAID

EDEN COLLINSWORTH

Arcade Publishing
Published: June 11, 2006
ISBN: 1559708123

Eden Collinsworth clearly has a powerful literary background, for the two central characters of this highly readable novel could be spin-offs of Fitzgerald's Gatsby, Edith Wharton's characters in Ethan Frome, and any of the real people in the biography of Maxwell Anderson, a pivotal publishing giant. Spin-off is okay and works well herein, but why is Isabella so irksome?

The plot is plain to see as the reader wanders through the story wondering how the irresponsible dandy, James, will continue his wannabe aristocratic lifestyle in a meaningful marriage to Isabel. Love is supposedly blind but Isabel takes the cake for acceptance; many another woman would have "flown the coop" or attempted to murder James chapters before Isabel actually does both.

Still this is a fascinating book in showing the demise of two literate writer/editor personalities, naturally reaching for the stars and descending into their darkest psychological substance. Who recovers? You will be surprised for sure by the ending of this capricious couple who manage to nurture a very sane son in the midst of veritable chaos on several sides of the Atlantic Ocean.

Fabulous, compelling read in one way but oddly devastating in outcome!

Reviewed by Viviane Crystal on November 24, 2006

e-mail to: literarymuse@hotmail.com