“Insanity Plea” is frequently one of the first defense tactics in a first degree murder case! It basically means that the alleged criminal was unable to control his or her behavior which resulted in the commission of homicide or murder. While this sounds very black and white, John Dicke has crafted a mystery novel in which a well-respected, former judge is charged with murder in what appears to be a very “open and shut” case. While the prosecutor is bound to prove only that a crime was committed, the defense counsel must only prove the “reasonable doubt” of guilt or sanity. Avery Jackson walked into a court and shot a new sheriff dead in full view of multiple witnesses. End of story? Grounds for doubt? Not!

Jack Maine the Public Defender, his partner, Yolanda Crone, and Jack's wife, Marci, begin an investigation that will uncover some amazing responsibility but not necessarily that of the defendant. Why would a person forget such a vivid crime? Amnesia? Trauma? How much corruption and murder lie in Avery Jackson's past? Who is to blame for what has led to this outrageous crime and a highly questionable trial? How much money is involved? Just what thoughts and feelings pass through a “criminal mind?” Is it possible that another can so influence the human mind to create a disordered or dysfunctional personality without care for one's lethal acts?

Since the public consensus has become cynical and suspecting over so many legal cases that seem obviously fraudulent or lacking in justice, this might be the perfect time to read this crime novel.

For, indeed, “all are to be presumed innocent unless proven otherwise.” John Dicke's novel is a MUST READ concerning the need for any jury member (and juries as a whole body) to realize his/her/their responsibility to balance the scales of justice based on “all” the facts in a case.

Masterfully plotted and told!

 

Reviewed by Viviane Crystal on March 30, 2006

e-mail to: literarymuse@hotmail.com